DB Multiverse
Member page of DissapointedReader

LMAO was saying:
You powerscaling people are always lacking when it comes to imagination. Maybe . . . just maybe . . . Goku watching multiple fights from XXI gives him an edge that the other fighters lacked? By your logic, SS0 Goku > Vegito, since Goku got out of the dimensional transport move faster than Vegito did? C'mon man.
1 Replie(s)
Alexis was saying: Here is my take on this fight.
To be continued.
So the guy who one shots Vegetto who was far stronger than Goku (granted he was taken by surprise with the time thingy from the dimension) one shots Zen Boo who is also a magician and far more powerful than Goku in every way, defeats Gast that may be weaker than Goku but as a magician could make Vegetto his bitch and was only killed by Zen Boo because fat Kai ended up making Gast believe Boo wasn't a threat anymore is going to have a dragged out fight against Goku and Goku has yet to get serious. Yup sounds legit, Toei is that you?
To be continued.
So the guy who one shots Vegetto who was far stronger than Goku (granted he was taken by surprise with the time thingy from the dimension) one shots Zen Boo who is also a magician and far more powerful than Goku in every way, defeats Gast that may be weaker than Goku but as a magician could make Vegetto his bitch and was only killed by Zen Boo because fat Kai ended up making Gast believe Boo wasn't a threat anymore is going to have a dragged out fight against Goku and Goku has yet to get serious. Yup sounds legit, Toei is that you?
twitch.tv/reileo was saying:
Another thing that "makes sense" is Frieza immediately killing everyone on Namek as opposed to toying with them and giving them the time to outsmart him and ultimately defeat him after Goku turns super saiyan. "Makes sense", but would make for a horrible story. "Making sense" is not the issue. A good fight here is more than warranted after 17 years of buildup from the standpoint of the narrative. And at the end of the day, a good narrative is all that matters. Goku could have tricked XXI with the afterimage technique and turned this into an entertaining tactical battle (Goku's martial arts vs XXI's magic). XXI could win and we could still get the same plot lines Salagir is pushing. Just like with Bra "giving up" against Gast in an OOC fashion, it just comes across as lazy writing.Mages are mages for a reason. What would really be wrong is a guy who dedicates his intellect to learning every kind of hack losing to someone who only knows how to throw punches.
"Oh, Salagir disrespected Goku." — No, he just took away the plot armor. Goku can be beloved, inspiring, a hero to many people. But if we don’t let our fanboy side speak louder and blind us, that’s exactly what would happen in many of his fights. XXI is a MAGE — and ONE MILLIONS OF YEARS OLD. Not even fucking Zen Buu could deal with him (at least not in time). Salagir already showed this with Vegetto.
Do you think an MMA fighter could even touch Gandalf? It’s exactly like that.
I play WoW, and if anyone here plays too, you know very well: mages are a warrior’s nightmare. When I’m on my mage, a warrior — no matter how good — barely touches me. There’s teleport, freezing, slow, invisibility, buff stealing, damage shields… It’s too much hacking.
So, like it or not, this makes sense — a lot of sense. Now we just have to wait for the fireworks to start. :P
"Oh, Salagir disrespected Goku." — No, he just took away the plot armor. Goku can be beloved, inspiring, a hero to many people. But if we don’t let our fanboy side speak louder and blind us, that’s exactly what would happen in many of his fights. XXI is a MAGE — and ONE MILLIONS OF YEARS OLD. Not even fucking Zen Buu could deal with him (at least not in time). Salagir already showed this with Vegetto.
Do you think an MMA fighter could even touch Gandalf? It’s exactly like that.
I play WoW, and if anyone here plays too, you know very well: mages are a warrior’s nightmare. When I’m on my mage, a warrior — no matter how good — barely touches me. There’s teleport, freezing, slow, invisibility, buff stealing, damage shields… It’s too much hacking.
So, like it or not, this makes sense — a lot of sense. Now we just have to wait for the fireworks to start. :P
SSJ2TeenTrunks was saying:
And unlike those tournaments, Goku here was effortlessly dispatched and did not give the ultimate winner a run for their money in a highly entertaining fight.
2 Replie(s)
Just like in canon Dragonball, Goku has entered into a tournament and has lost once again, but the tournaments end brings new adventures to the gang!
Delphince was saying:
I thought they revived everyone between rounds.
Uhh...wasn't EVERYONE that died in their match supposed to be revived? Why is Goku getting individual treatment? Even if this is a version of Porunga that can only revive one person at a time, I don't see them making or even discussing any attempt to bring back the other dead before the final reward ceremony.
South_Ferry was saying:
let's be real, we ALL expected goku to be one shotted instantly,
we ALL know the tournament and this comic will have a grand finale with countless fullpage spreads and beautiful asura art,
we ALL know the whole arena is about to be genocided
the question is how will they do it?
we ALL know the tournament and this comic will have a grand finale with countless fullpage spreads and beautiful asura art,
we ALL know the whole arena is about to be genocided
the question is how will they do it?
Speak for yourself.
Neither me nor most of the readers (judging by comment on previous pages) expected Goku to be one shotted instantly. That come as a shock.
Given that they had Goku get one shotted, I have no idea why we should assume the tournament and this comic will have a grand finale with countless fullpage spreads and beautiful asura art. Sounds like wishful thinking. Salagir might do something else subsersive and steal the ending the Shaman King by letting XXI's be the winner all around, lol.
ZenBuu was saying:
I'll keep the rule violation in mind. Apologies. Haven't posted here in ages. And I've long passed the point in my life where bad writing in a comic book can register any kind of emotion from me outside of disappointment (hence my username). The last 20 years of my life have been a painful lesson in priorities. I think deviating too much from the tournament angle is a mistake and think all of the divergent arcs (especially Majin Bra, IKL, Kakaditz and the Buu Rebellion) have been unnecessary. Being a seasoned writer myself, I do have a theory about Salagir's feelings on the direction of this comic and when he started developing these feelings, but I'll respect the rules and leave it at that.A lot of you are breaking rule #13 at this point! Please refrain from second guessing what exactly Salagir has in mind, you can't read his thoughts.
For example things like:
"Salagir is obviously burned out at this point, he's not motivated anymore; Salagir won't treat Goku with respect anymore in the future; that's it, DBM is over" and stuff like that.
Discuss, but in a friendly manner, without getting insulting. This is still Salagir's comic. Frankly, he doesn't owe anybody here anything, he can still do whatever he wants with his own story, wether you like it or absolutely disagree with it.
I'd honestly suggest that some people may take a break from DBM to cool off a little bit, because some of you are getting a little bit too heated and emotional over all of this, even to the point, where you seem to lose all objectivity. Maybe do something else that you actually enjoy and come back at a later time. Even if you may be disappointed, this is not the end of the world, life goes on.
For example things like:
"Salagir is obviously burned out at this point, he's not motivated anymore; Salagir won't treat Goku with respect anymore in the future; that's it, DBM is over" and stuff like that.
Discuss, but in a friendly manner, without getting insulting. This is still Salagir's comic. Frankly, he doesn't owe anybody here anything, he can still do whatever he wants with his own story, wether you like it or absolutely disagree with it.
I'd honestly suggest that some people may take a break from DBM to cool off a little bit, because some of you are getting a little bit too heated and emotional over all of this, even to the point, where you seem to lose all objectivity. Maybe do something else that you actually enjoy and come back at a later time. Even if you may be disappointed, this is not the end of the world, life goes on.
PokeChess was saying:
Ve-Gui-To's explanation creates a plot hole. Piccolo clearly reacted to IKL's technique before its activation as explained on the prior page and Goku's senses and speed are a bajillion times greater than Piccolo's as shown during the Goku vs Vegeta fight. Therefore, it stands to reason that Goku would have not only sensed the time stop much faster than Piccolo, but would have either (A) retaliated or (B) set up a fakeout via after-image much like he did when Frieza tried to cut him in half in the original manga. I get they're for whatever reason committed to this idea of Goku losing instantly and that they are never going to admit that a full fledged fight would have been more satisfying to many loyal readers who have supported this series for 17 years, but the way they executed it is just not good writing. I would have been more impressed had XII asked the dragon to give Goku the heart virus again and that dulled his senses just enough for IKL to finish him off via timestop. But oh well! pip25 was saying: But instead, Goku lost like a moron.
Every single opponent of XXI, even Vegetto who confronted him first, knew that they should not give him the chance to cast any spells or use other magic. Heck, even Goku showed awareness of this fact at the start of the match, when he tried to arrange things so he could transform PRIOR to the beginning of the battle. So then, after breaking out of XXI's alternate dimension, why, just WHY in the name of all kaio shins did he simply stand there, monolouging like an idiot??? That was his chance, his ONLY chance in fact to strike back, and he wasted it. According to Vegeta, less than a second is pretty much "an eternity" in this form, so he apparently wasted more than an eternity to brag - and paid for it with his life. His defeat is utterly humiliating.
MUI was saying: First of all: Why such disrespect towards Goku? Canon Goku is a very intelligent fighter. Knowing him, he wouldn’t give XXI even a second to use his magic, especially after seeing firsthand what it did to fighters like Zen Buu and Vegetto. But as soon as he breaks out of the time dimension, he starts talking to XXI very nonchalantly about random trivial things giving XXI all the time of the world for his next move.
On DBM’s Discord (just for reference, Asura is the one who drew it and Veguito is the one who helped):
Ve-Gui-To! said he thinks people are thrown off by Goku talking, but that in any case Goku couldn’t have done anything against XXI’s time freeze without knowing about it. I replied that, to be fair, Goku could have still tried to attack quickly before saying anything, but I didn’t really blame that because it’s part of his personality.
Ve-Gui-To! said that losing instantly is not something that would be skipped anyway and asked how it would make sense for XXI not to win instantly now that his abilities are known. He also joked that Goku starting to move inside the time freeze like he’s Jotaro wouldn’t make sense.
I answered that maybe Goku could have hit the old man’s body first — possibly destroying it — and then XXI would stop time and defeat him anyway. It would still be an instant loss but at least Goku would have landed some kind of blow first. Ve-Gui-To! said he didn’t really see how that would be more satisfying.
I explained that the idea was just that people would feel Goku didn’t just stand there talking and that he was the only one besides Zen Buu to destroy the old man’s body, even if people would still complain. Someone else wondered if Goku might have explored the dimension to understand XXI, but Ve-Gui-To! said he didn’t really have much time for that and added that the talking was there for dramatic effect: Goku escapes the dimension, then gets time frozen, and in manga a lot of dialogue can happen in a split second.
I asked if Goku wouldn’t have time to do something before XXI since he’s so fast and pointed out he spoke a few words without a hole in his chest. (The image said: “But he has to break out in less than 0.08 seconds! I calculated it.”) Ve-Gui-To! said again it was for dramatic effect and that it throws people off, but it’s normal manga rules.
Asura added that it’s theatrical and that XXI could have used the IKL technique the moment Goku was teleported. I asked Asura to confirm if even if Goku moved in under 0.08 seconds XXI would still stop him immediately. Ve-Gui-To! explained that the time feels longer for the reader because the pages come out days apart, but in the story XXI would freeze time the instant the dimension breaks.
Someone else pointed out that XXI also had almost 30 seconds to activate it. (Asura reacted with the :point_up_2: emoji.) I added that my idea was that XXI probably pre-cast the spell, so it would be instant just like against Zen Buu. The same person summed it up simply: teleport Goku, wait for him to come back, freeze him, attack.
Ve-Gui-To! said XXI probably could have frozen time first anyway but tried the dimension first to keep that trick hidden. Another person said the ideal was that the teleport alone would work so XXI wouldn’t have to show the time stop yet.
Every single opponent of XXI, even Vegetto who confronted him first, knew that they should not give him the chance to cast any spells or use other magic. Heck, even Goku showed awareness of this fact at the start of the match, when he tried to arrange things so he could transform PRIOR to the beginning of the battle. So then, after breaking out of XXI's alternate dimension, why, just WHY in the name of all kaio shins did he simply stand there, monolouging like an idiot??? That was his chance, his ONLY chance in fact to strike back, and he wasted it. According to Vegeta, less than a second is pretty much "an eternity" in this form, so he apparently wasted more than an eternity to brag - and paid for it with his life. His defeat is utterly humiliating.
MUI was saying: First of all: Why such disrespect towards Goku? Canon Goku is a very intelligent fighter. Knowing him, he wouldn’t give XXI even a second to use his magic, especially after seeing firsthand what it did to fighters like Zen Buu and Vegetto. But as soon as he breaks out of the time dimension, he starts talking to XXI very nonchalantly about random trivial things giving XXI all the time of the world for his next move.
On DBM’s Discord (just for reference, Asura is the one who drew it and Veguito is the one who helped):
Ve-Gui-To! said he thinks people are thrown off by Goku talking, but that in any case Goku couldn’t have done anything against XXI’s time freeze without knowing about it. I replied that, to be fair, Goku could have still tried to attack quickly before saying anything, but I didn’t really blame that because it’s part of his personality.
Ve-Gui-To! said that losing instantly is not something that would be skipped anyway and asked how it would make sense for XXI not to win instantly now that his abilities are known. He also joked that Goku starting to move inside the time freeze like he’s Jotaro wouldn’t make sense.
I answered that maybe Goku could have hit the old man’s body first — possibly destroying it — and then XXI would stop time and defeat him anyway. It would still be an instant loss but at least Goku would have landed some kind of blow first. Ve-Gui-To! said he didn’t really see how that would be more satisfying.
I explained that the idea was just that people would feel Goku didn’t just stand there talking and that he was the only one besides Zen Buu to destroy the old man’s body, even if people would still complain. Someone else wondered if Goku might have explored the dimension to understand XXI, but Ve-Gui-To! said he didn’t really have much time for that and added that the talking was there for dramatic effect: Goku escapes the dimension, then gets time frozen, and in manga a lot of dialogue can happen in a split second.
I asked if Goku wouldn’t have time to do something before XXI since he’s so fast and pointed out he spoke a few words without a hole in his chest. (The image said: “But he has to break out in less than 0.08 seconds! I calculated it.”) Ve-Gui-To! said again it was for dramatic effect and that it throws people off, but it’s normal manga rules.
Asura added that it’s theatrical and that XXI could have used the IKL technique the moment Goku was teleported. I asked Asura to confirm if even if Goku moved in under 0.08 seconds XXI would still stop him immediately. Ve-Gui-To! explained that the time feels longer for the reader because the pages come out days apart, but in the story XXI would freeze time the instant the dimension breaks.
Someone else pointed out that XXI also had almost 30 seconds to activate it. (Asura reacted with the :point_up_2: emoji.) I added that my idea was that XXI probably pre-cast the spell, so it would be instant just like against Zen Buu. The same person summed it up simply: teleport Goku, wait for him to come back, freeze him, attack.
Ve-Gui-To! said XXI probably could have frozen time first anyway but tried the dimension first to keep that trick hidden. Another person said the ideal was that the teleport alone would work so XXI wouldn’t have to show the time stop yet.
Bird Mountain was saying:
I’ve seen people call this latest plot turn a “constellation of disappointment” — and honestly, what a phrase. I’m stealing it.
I've got a million of 'em. ;-)I’ve seen people call this latest plot turn a “constellation of disappointment” — and honestly, what a phrase. I’m stealing it.
Daisetsu was saying:
After a full fledged fight with which Tien got the crap beaten out of him and barely won by a fluke . . . yes. I find it funny how many people claim Goku should be treated with more respect, just for being the main character, when he lost against Tenshinhan because of a car.
Justanotherturtle was saying:
Well said and this is something I think the DBM team keeps forgetting. This is not an independent work. This is a fancomic of an existing work. Some additional world building and OC characters is fine and even appreciated, but at the end of the day, readers are here because of their love for the characters Toriyama created.
iron leaf was saying: But newly introduced characters are usually the focus of new arcs. In an abstract way, every new character in a new arc would be an OC. For example. Pilaf arc has established the first characters. This means that later Red Ribbon are all OC. And later Tien and Piccolo, etc. Let's look at Future Trunks not from the perspective of a DB fan, but someone who only knows DB up to the Freeza Arc, and then is suddenly confronted with Future Trunks. You would instinctively roll your eyes. Why of all things the newly introduced character (in an abstract way an OC to previous established story with all the characters) is an SSJ1, and defeats Freeza. Makes everyone (except Goku) look old. DBM is a new arc after EoZ in an abstract way. Strictly speaking, when a fanfic introduces OCs, I actually expect them to be relevant. We don't need something like the Magical Girls from U6.
You're making the mistake of treating fanfiction with the same rules as original fiction. Toriyama had more freedom to do what he wanted with Dragon Ball than someone writing Dragon Ball fanfic. This might sound unfair, but it's because Toriyama had to come up with an entire world from scratch, whereas Salagir is just using Toriyama's setting.
When people read Dragon Ball fiction, whether fanfic or officially published canon, they want to read about Dragon Ball characters. This is a non-factor in officially published works because all the characters are Dragon Ball characters. In fanfic however, only the characters that existed in canon are truly Dragon Ball characters.
People were reading this for fights between Dragon Ball characters. People wanted to see which Dragon Ball character would win the tournament. It's sort of okay to have an OC as a struggle for a Dragon Ball character overcome, but the focus should be on the canon characters.
Who is the greatest Dragon Ball character of all time after they reach their full potential? Is it Cell after he trained and honed himself? Is it Buu after making full use of his absorptions? King Cold after training and discovering higher forms? Ginyu after sneakily using his body change and training? Broly with his constantly rising power? Or is it still Vegetto sitting supreme? Oh, I'm sorry, the greatest Dragon Ball character of all time is some guy who Salagir made up and therefore isn't even a Dragon Ball character, silly me.
Do you see why that might be unsatisfying?
I'm aware that there is going to be more story after this. But I don't think that works. Why should they fight him after this? He won the tournament fairly, they shouldn't have the right to stop him. The only one who knew about his evil nature has been sent back to universe 9, nobody else should oppose his wish. They don't know that he's going to wish for multiversal travel so they have no motive to stop him. They think he's going to make one wish for universe 19 and then maybe two harmless wishes for himself. It really doesn't make sense for them to fight him after this.
You're making the mistake of treating fanfiction with the same rules as original fiction. Toriyama had more freedom to do what he wanted with Dragon Ball than someone writing Dragon Ball fanfic. This might sound unfair, but it's because Toriyama had to come up with an entire world from scratch, whereas Salagir is just using Toriyama's setting.
When people read Dragon Ball fiction, whether fanfic or officially published canon, they want to read about Dragon Ball characters. This is a non-factor in officially published works because all the characters are Dragon Ball characters. In fanfic however, only the characters that existed in canon are truly Dragon Ball characters.
People were reading this for fights between Dragon Ball characters. People wanted to see which Dragon Ball character would win the tournament. It's sort of okay to have an OC as a struggle for a Dragon Ball character overcome, but the focus should be on the canon characters.
Who is the greatest Dragon Ball character of all time after they reach their full potential? Is it Cell after he trained and honed himself? Is it Buu after making full use of his absorptions? King Cold after training and discovering higher forms? Ginyu after sneakily using his body change and training? Broly with his constantly rising power? Or is it still Vegetto sitting supreme? Oh, I'm sorry, the greatest Dragon Ball character of all time is some guy who Salagir made up and therefore isn't even a Dragon Ball character, silly me.
Do you see why that might be unsatisfying?
I'm aware that there is going to be more story after this. But I don't think that works. Why should they fight him after this? He won the tournament fairly, they shouldn't have the right to stop him. The only one who knew about his evil nature has been sent back to universe 9, nobody else should oppose his wish. They don't know that he's going to wish for multiversal travel so they have no motive to stop him. They think he's going to make one wish for universe 19 and then maybe two harmless wishes for himself. It really doesn't make sense for them to fight him after this.
LurkCypher was saying:
The Vegito eating the bean from XXI is the biggest indication to me that Salagir does not have this 'well-planned 4D chess narrative masterstroke that we just need to sit back and watch play out' that people continually tout. Don't get me wrong. For the most part, I had fun reading DBM these past 17 years and I am thankful for the work put into it. However, it has become increasingly apparent to me that Salagir is burnt out on this series. The Vegito bean reeks of hamfisted writing; Salagir could not be bothered to think of a more natural explanation for 'evil Vegetto" so he just throws in the most OOC fanfic tier explanation one could muster. The way South Kai is acting is extremely forced as well (to the point where readers are suggesting that maybe he is being mind controlled).
I'm disappointed. Through all the years I've been following DBM, I've always accepted the explanation that things will eventually pay off, even when they seemed weird at some moment. And sometimes they did pay off. Other times, not so much. But the overall experience remained very good! I've also come to expect some healthy dose of trolling from Salagir, so I often thought many readers just complain too much...
Well, not anymore. I made an account right after reading the previous page, just to comment how terrible it was, but I held off in some hopes of it being yet another trolling page. Doesn't look like it, so I'm saying it now. Ending the tournament in such an anticlimactic way was a really, relly poor idea. An idea that came directly after the "Recruitment" chapter, in which characters behaved in such a stupid way (like South Kaioshin attacking Elder Kaioshin and not listening to the concerns U9 had about I'k'l, or Vegetto eating the bean from XXI) that it completely broke my suspension of disbelief. I don't know if the noticeably decreased quality of recent chapters is a result of burnout or anything else... but suffice to say I won't be getting my hopes up about the rest of the comic.
Well, not anymore. I made an account right after reading the previous page, just to comment how terrible it was, but I held off in some hopes of it being yet another trolling page. Doesn't look like it, so I'm saying it now. Ending the tournament in such an anticlimactic way was a really, relly poor idea. An idea that came directly after the "Recruitment" chapter, in which characters behaved in such a stupid way (like South Kaioshin attacking Elder Kaioshin and not listening to the concerns U9 had about I'k'l, or Vegetto eating the bean from XXI) that it completely broke my suspension of disbelief. I don't know if the noticeably decreased quality of recent chapters is a result of burnout or anything else... but suffice to say I won't be getting my hopes up about the rest of the comic.
ArmorMothra was saying:
Even with timestop, if PIccolo is fast enough to "sense the wave" as soon as it is launched, I don't see why a cautious SS0 Goku does not either use after image and then instant transmission away from XXI's line of sight or just instantly blitz XXI with a visceral attack and win on the spot. This is the same SS0 that had half of an entire battle with Vegeta before people could even blink. If I were writing this fight, I might be tempted to use to same shock value scene here, but it would definitely end with a fakeout and Goku making XXI regret not asking the dragon for a way to defeat Goku instead of assuming timestop would automatically be enough. We could have then gotten a more creative fight where if XXI won it was by the skin of his teeth. But oh well!LordUzaki was saying: This was the only way this fight was ever going to end.
Goku would have won without time-stop. Goku is stronger than Gast and XXI was out of tricks.
Goku would have won without time-stop. Goku is stronger than Gast and XXI was out of tricks.
The funny thing is that there are many ways we could have kept the tournament angle while diving into whatever Salagir has cooking. See other series with "the world is at stake" tournaments (Yugioh, Yu Yu Hakusho, etc). I just don't understand why Salagir feels the need to go ahead and end the most interesting part of this series.
ArmorMothra was saying:
You joke but anything after imperfect cell was garbage. Perfect cell is a horrible villain.
You're not wrong. Most of Perfect Cell's popularity stems from his excellent and memorable voice actor, Dameon Clark. He sparked life into that character that the original Japanese couldn't. I recommend people watch PlagueofGripes Cell games video. He does a pretty good job highlighting how when you look past some of the cool set pieces (i.e. Gohan's kamehameha clash with Cell and his SSJ2 transformation in general), the Cell games is very poorly written.
You joke but anything after imperfect cell was garbage. Perfect cell is a horrible villain.
ArmorMothra was saying:
It's not so much that he is evil but that he is winning matches with extremely specific counters to his opponents. I think that's enough to raise red flags and have trouble believing none of them would have given Old Kai their attention notwithstanding their prior relationship with him in their own universe. This guy helped them save their own universe from Majin Buu. Call me crazy, but I think that history would warrant at least a full on conversation about his concerns as opposed to blowing him off in the way we saw here. I have a hard time believing that U18 would not have at least tried to come up with some counter-measure to instant-win attacks given that such counter-measures exist (i.e. after images and multi form). This is not at all out of character for Goku given that he literally does just this while watching on the sidelines in every prior tournament---recall how he was able to neutralize the solar flare against Tien because he had already watched Tien use it on Jackie Chun). Lot of wasted potential. Tactical/Creative Goku is not out of character; Toriyama just stopped using him after Dragon Ball.
1 Replie(s)
DissapointedReader was saying: The way XXI has gotten by without more efforts to stop or deal with him in advance is every bit as "stupid" as what you just described. XXI would have been under a lot more suspicion with his EXTREMELY specific wins over 18, Buu and Gast
Why is that? XXI hasn't done anything illegal or even showing evil intent, there would have been no reason to be suspicious of him. I'd be more inclined to believe you later once elder kai started sounding the alarm bells but even that is contestable.
Why is that? XXI hasn't done anything illegal or even showing evil intent, there would have been no reason to be suspicious of him. I'd be more inclined to believe you later once elder kai started sounding the alarm bells but even that is contestable.
ArmorMothra was saying:
The way XXI has gotten by without more efforts to stop or deal with him in advance is every bit as "stupid" as what you just described. XXI would have been under a lot more suspicion with his EXTREMELY specific wins over 18, Buu and Gast (even if Goku is an idiot, Vegeta, Piccolo and Gohan and Buu are not and none of them are above investigation in advance). Gast surely would have ratted him out for attacking him after he had forfeited. U18 would have taken Old Kai a lot more seriously with his warnings about XXI given their preexisting relationship in their own universe. It should tell you something how readers are consistently complaining about how stupid South Kai is behaving with everything regarding XXI's behavior. The only reason XXI has progressed to the final round (and WON the tournament apparently) is because of the very kind of stupidity you are referencing with Frieza. It would have made a lot more sense had we gotten a "night before" chapter with Gohan and company discussing the matter with Old Kai at length and doing some snooping in advance of the match----which might have allowed Goku to be more prepared for instant-attacks----like using after image or multiform as bait). Don't even get me started on VEGITO EATING A SENZU BEAN FROM XXI. By far the best example of CHARACTER INDUCED STUPIDITY in this entire series.
1 Replie(s)
Kururun was saying:
I think this is more of a "you" issue than a Dragon Ball issue. The characters make a few blunders in the Cell arc but generally speaking not that much, and the few "stupid" moments are just because things just aren't that serious.
I think you are massively underestimating the frequency of these stupid moments. Frieza not killing the Z fighters even though they've passed any other opponent in power and keep forcing him into higher forms, not fusing to defeat buu, everything in cell like you said. There are many more but I don't want to get into a tit for tat about each one since that is besides the point and in any case I don't really want to discuss DBZ very much at all due to lack of interest (aside from a few minor things I find interesting and salvageable). There's also the extremely poorly done powerscaling, nonsensical jumps in power, inconsistent and unbelievable scaling, etc.
I think this is more of a "you" issue than a Dragon Ball issue. The characters make a few blunders in the Cell arc but generally speaking not that much, and the few "stupid" moments are just because things just aren't that serious.
I think you are massively underestimating the frequency of these stupid moments. Frieza not killing the Z fighters even though they've passed any other opponent in power and keep forcing him into higher forms, not fusing to defeat buu, everything in cell like you said. There are many more but I don't want to get into a tit for tat about each one since that is besides the point and in any case I don't really want to discuss DBZ very much at all due to lack of interest (aside from a few minor things I find interesting and salvageable). There's also the extremely poorly done powerscaling, nonsensical jumps in power, inconsistent and unbelievable scaling, etc.
RetroOVER9000 was saying:
In hindsight, the ONLY narrative function IKL served was to make XXI more powerful. The whole IKL arc is otherwise misplaced and irrelevant to this story (hence why IKL is even heard saying ZA WARUDO when using this technique).I was cool with Bra, I even enjoyed her arc. Unlike most. This however is just bad writing. In DB Villains don't just one shot the main characters to show they are tough. Even Perfect Cell didn't just one shot Vegeta. I don't know, this feels kind of cheap. Like this should have been a multi chapter battle, but they go "Let's just give him time freeze powers" ... like, really? That's just cheating. I don't care. We better see a very upset Vegito soon.
Gast Greatness was saying:
Never made sense why nobody took him up on his offer for a secondary tournament or why they immediately needed to escalate to another free for all battle with him. He wasn't bothering anybody. I took it as just a "Oh shit; we made Zen Buu too powerful; lets think of some lame and unsatisfying reason to write him out the story, but lets still have him train Uub in magic offscreen in case we have need of some deus ex machina (kind of like the one we used to have Zen Buu fix everything after Bra came to her senses) in case we write ourselves into another corner which we probably will by giving XXI timestop powers!"I just had another epiphany; Zen Buu suggesting opening a Secondary Tournament (Page 1992) in parallel makes sense. He realized that this was a magic tournament and not a martial arts tournament. He figured out the deception, that's why he suggested it XD.
ArmorMothra was saying:
DBM has much worse issues with pacing and characters acting stupid. The way the Majin Bra thing resolved was a complete train wreck for reasons readers here have beaten to death over and over and over again. The whole Zen Buu vs Everyone II was completely forced and pointless. The IKL arc came out of nowhere and is literally just there to justify XXI's cheap and unsatisfying win here. The what-if Kakadiz arc was pointless. I'm not denying that DBZ has massively bad writing (it does primarily after the saiyan saga and really ramped up during the Cell and Buu sagas), but Salagir has very little room to talk. If this were 10+ years ago, I would have a completely different opinion. Not any more. It does some things better, but does a lot of stuff worse. I can't in a million years imagine Toriyama taking the premier fight everyone has been waiting on (Goku vs XXI) and giving readers this constellation of disappointment.
DBZFan92 was saying: Goku didn't need to win or put up a fight in my opinion, it just wouldn't have made much sense at this point.
I don't think an XXI victory was inevitable at all. He was out of tricks until I'K'L showed up. I think probably he wished for I'K'L final beam to split and hit him too or something like that. Redirecting a beam would take a lot less power than just straight up giving that ability from nothing. If it weren't for that I think Goku and XXI would have fought an extremely close fight with Goku ultimately winning. You say the real conflict would have started after the tournament and I agree, but I cannot understand in what world it would not have been better to have a good fight IN the tournament and then outside of it also.
DissapointedReader was saying:
DBZ might have been poorly made, but DBM has just as many writing problems (if not more). Don't even get me started on how the Majin Bra arc resolved.
DBM has far, far less issues with powerscaling, plotholes, and characters acting stupid than DBZ ever did. Not to say those issues don't exist but they're far less egregious. I maintain DBM's biggest issue is its pacing and how towards the end everything is beginning to feel rushed.
I don't think an XXI victory was inevitable at all. He was out of tricks until I'K'L showed up. I think probably he wished for I'K'L final beam to split and hit him too or something like that. Redirecting a beam would take a lot less power than just straight up giving that ability from nothing. If it weren't for that I think Goku and XXI would have fought an extremely close fight with Goku ultimately winning. You say the real conflict would have started after the tournament and I agree, but I cannot understand in what world it would not have been better to have a good fight IN the tournament and then outside of it also.
DissapointedReader was saying:
DBZ might have been poorly made, but DBM has just as many writing problems (if not more). Don't even get me started on how the Majin Bra arc resolved.
DBM has far, far less issues with powerscaling, plotholes, and characters acting stupid than DBZ ever did. Not to say those issues don't exist but they're far less egregious. I maintain DBM's biggest issue is its pacing and how towards the end everything is beginning to feel rushed.
ArmorMothra was saying:
Anyone else think Salagir is burnt out at this point and is trying to end DBM as soon as possible? I'm not as disturbed by this turn of events as some but despite agreeing with Salagir generally that DBZ is poorly made I think DBM's biggest weakness is its pacing issues. I was initially fine with the whole Majin Rebellion but I've become more critical of it recently since it didn't really lead to anything and because it was so long in comparison to more important moments later on. I just imagined every key moment after would have been even longer so in the moment that made it okay in my eyes.
Another problem with this segment in general here is that they keep XXI in his ugly old man form. After Buu there should have been no reason whatsoever for him to continue with that avatar, or at least make it a cooler looking avatar. Keep it unassuming if you want but it should at least be aesthetic.
Is there a place for more extended discussion? It would be fun to share ideas with others on how to rewrite this series.
Another problem with this segment in general here is that they keep XXI in his ugly old man form. After Buu there should have been no reason whatsoever for him to continue with that avatar, or at least make it a cooler looking avatar. Keep it unassuming if you want but it should at least be aesthetic.
Is there a place for more extended discussion? It would be fun to share ideas with others on how to rewrite this series.
DBZ might have been poorly made, but DBM has just as many writing problems (if not more). Don't even get me started on how the Majin Bra arc resolved.
Agreed that Salagir must be burnt out. I suspected it as soon as he had Bra give up to Gast, but this right here confirms it in my mind. 1 Replie(s)
People grumble why content for (approx)10 pages wasn't squeezed into a single page.
Don't expect a complete chapter when we have Publish-Day on DBM. It's always only one page.
Self designated tournament police. I think that's how the DB Canon police see themselves, telling people what is and isn't allowed in a fanfic. xD
I dunno. Suggesting certain readers think of themselves as canon police sounds an awful lot like second guessing what certain readers have in mind. I don't believe any of us have confirmed thinking of ourselves as canon police just because we make the occassional criticism here and there, but what do I know? xD
Imagine all the dietary restrictions